It all seemed very simple - we had stocked Green and Blacks delicious organic chocolate since the shop opened, but Fairtrade Fortnight earlier in the year gave us pause for thought, and we ordered a few lines of Divine chocolate which sports the logo of the Fairtrade Foundation, which led us to wonder what our customers and our consciences preferred - organic or fairtrade ?
We searched around a bit for a brand that might actually marry the two - after all G and B do have a Fairtrade Mayan Gold chocolate, but our research was confounded by last week's Panorama programme on the chocolate trade, and the consequent comments of many of our customers.
It would seem that the industry, Fairtrade or not, may still be harbouring issues which consumers in the west find unpalatable - namely the use of child labour on the cocoa plantations.
However, to quote from Trading Visions, an organisation which claims to "amplify the voices of small scale producers",
'The focus in the Panorama documentary on incidences of child labour among farmers supplying cocoa to two Fairtrade cooperatives in Ghana and Cote d'Ivoire reminds us that the Fairtrade Mark does not guarantee “no child labour”, it guarantees a fair price to farmers and a Fairtrade premium to farmers' organisations. However Fairtrade does clearly emerge in the documentary as the only credible system that can trace cocoa back to individual farms and thus take remedial action when breaches of standards on child labour are identified.'
Literally food for thought ......